Director, Insurance Company Partnerships (ICP)
Job Summary
Leads Baldwin’s relationships with its insurance company partners (ICPs). Negotiates agreements, compensation, and program terms that create profitable growth for both Baldwin and the carrier. Manages a panel of personal lines carriers across Baldwin’s agencies, offices, and SubAgency partners. Works with leaders across Baldwin segments to manage shared carrier relationships from a holistic view. Reports results and risks to Executive Leadership.
Primary Functions
Owns the strategy, performance, and governance of Baldwin’s carrier relationships. Maximizes carrier compensation through profit share, contingent, and commission agreements. Aligns carrier programs with Baldwin’s growth and profitability goals. Acts as Baldwin’s lead contact for carrier executives, marketing, and underwriting leaders.
Duties and Responsibilities
Relationship Management
- Builds and maintains executive-level relationships with carrier leaders
- Serves as the primary point of contact for assigned carriers
- Holds regular business reviews on performance, appetite, and priorities
- Resolves escalated issues with carriers promptly and professionally
- Represents Baldwin at carrier meetings, conferences, and events
Negotiation and Contracts
- Negotiates agreements, commission schedules, and profit share and contingent programs
- Reviews contract terms and compares them year over year to find changes in value
- Evaluates program decisions such as lock-ins, stop-loss elections, and renewals
- Works with Legal and Compliance to review and execute agreements
- Tracks deadlines, elections, and obligations in every agreement
Carrier Optimization
- Develops a strategy for each carrier by tier, with clear goals and owners
- Analyzes production, retention, and loss ratios to guide placement and growth plans
- Balances Baldwin’s compensation goals with the carrier’s profitability targets
- Identifies new carrier opportunities and recommends when to exit or reduce a relationship
- Aligns carrier strategy with sales, operations, and producer leaders
Performance Tracking and Reporting
- Monitors carrier performance against annual and quarterly targets
- Forecasts and reconciles expected payouts with Finance
- Reports carrier results, risks, and opportunities to Executive Leadership
- Maintains accurate records of agreements, terms, and commitments
Cross-Segment Collaboration
- Partners with other Baldwin segments on carriers shared across the business
- Coordinates carrier messaging and negotiating positions across segments
- Confirms the correct entity, code, and segment for each agreement
- Supports onboarding, appointments, and code changes for new partners, offices, and acquisitions
Governance
- Maintains access, appointment, and contact records for each carrier
- Manages carrier notices for changes such as addresses, entities, and contacts
- Flags risks that could affect compensation, compliance, or reputation
- Participates in educational and professional development programs
Qualifications
- 10+ years of personal lines insurance experience
- Proven experience managing carrier or partner relationships at the executive level
- Strong negotiation skills, including commercial and contract terms
- Working knowledge of profit share, contingent, and commission structures
- Strong analytical skills, including loss ratio, retention, and growth analysis
- Clear written and verbal communication
- Ability to work across teams and influence without direct authority
- Strategic, independent, and results-oriented
- Sound judgment and discretion with confidential carrier, agency, and financial information
- Proficiency in Excel, Word, Outlook, and agency management systems
- Active Property & Casualty license
- Bachelor’s degree preferred
- Flexibility to travel and to work outside regular hours as needed
#LI-KL1
IND1
Click here for some insight into our culture!
The Baldwin Group will not accept unsolicited resumes from any source other than directly from a candidate who applies on our career site. Any unsolicited resumes sent to The Baldwin Group, including unsolicited resumes sent via any source from an Agency, will not be considered and are not subject to any fees for any placement resulting from the receipt of an unsolicited resume.
Similar Jobs
What you need to know about the Colorado Tech Scene
Key Facts About Colorado Tech
- Number of Tech Workers: 260,000; 8.5% of overall workforce (2024 CompTIA survey)
- Major Tech Employers: Lockheed Martin, Century Link, Comcast, BAE Systems, Level 3
- Key Industries: Software, artificial intelligence, aerospace, e-commerce, fintech, healthtech
- Funding Landscape: $4.9 billion in VC funding in 2024 (Pitchbook)
- Notable Investors: Access Venture Partners, Ridgeline Ventures, Techstars, Blackhorn Ventures
- Research Centers and Universities: Colorado School of Mines, University of Colorado Boulder, University of Denver, Colorado State University, Mesa Laboratory, Space Science Institute, National Center for Atmospheric Research, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Gottlieb Institute


